Internal Audit - Is It Truly Independent?

Internal Audit is appointed by management. While professional CEOs who genuinely value continuous improvement often maintain an arm's-length relationship with Internal Audit, others may cringe at the thought that a group of people known as "Internal Auditors" could expose weaknesses in their armour that may ultimately lead a governing body to question their performance.

As most internal auditors are engaged either as employees of a company or as external service providers, it can be difficult to see how true independence can ever be fully achieved. It takes a highly professional internal auditor to call things as they are while knowing there is a risk of losing a client or even their employment.

Organisations should implement strong governance arrangements. Internal Audit should report to a governing body, whether that be an Audit Committee or a Board. However, what happens if the governing body does not want to hear the message?

Unfettered access, dual reporting lines, audit charters and professional standards are all important. Yet even these measures may never achieve complete independence. So, what is the answer?

The answer may lie in recruitment and training. Perhaps we should acknowledge that absolute independence can never truly be achieved. The same argument could even be made for external auditors, as large accounting firms may face similar challenges.

By all means, implement an audit charter. Establish internal audit positions as non-operational roles. Maintain dual reporting lines, promote objectivity and ensure auditors present their periodic reports directly to the governing body. However, in the end, it is the values, character and culture of all parties involved that will determine whether an organisation succeeds.

Perhaps the answer is ensuring that integrity is the number one characteristic sought when recruiting and developing auditors. Equally important is whether the message of continuous improvement, rather than fear of scrutiny, is genuinely understood throughout the organisation.

It is also possible that Internal Audit can become too distant from the business. In some cases, doing the opposite may be the answer. Rather than being seen less, the Internal Audit function may need to be seen and heard more.

Should part of the Internal Audit role involve becoming more visible and educating the organisation about the importance of the function? Internal Audit is fundamentally about continuous improvement. The reward for embracing this philosophy is organisational prosperity and, ultimately, the creation of sustainable employment.

In light of this discussion, the sooner an organisation establishes a sustainable compliance and risk management framework, embracing the view that management, the governing body, Internal Audit and employees are all working together towards achieving strategic goals, the more likely the organisation is to achieve sustained success.

Mario Bruno CPA MBA
Chief Compliance Officer

CommRisk – ‘Combining Compliance, Risk and Internal Audit in an AI World’